The latter means those deceptive journals with tricky names that mislead the authors making them confuse with the original genuine journals. By all accounts, the probability of the revised list containing more predatory journals cannot be ruled out. I decided to publish a list of pseudoscientific and predatory journals and publishers. Predatory journals are scam publishers that charge authors fees upfront, but do not provide the service they promise. See Table 1 (Page 6) On the other hand, the effort by DOAJ is aimed at identifying legitimate Open Access Journals. Avoid these journals. The number of predatory journals is increasing day-by-day and also getting more difficult to identify. It will be updated as new information or suggested edits are submitted or found by the maintainers of this site.) Jeffrey Beall, the most renowned, started to set up a list of predatory journals in 2008. To quantify content overlaps between blacklists and whitelists, we employed the Jaro-Winkler string metric. Many predatory journals will make up an impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable. Jeffrey Beall, a librarian at the University of Colorado Denver, had compiled lists of "potential, possible, or probable predatory" journals and publishers.As of January 2017 the list is no longer updated. The problem had ballooned into a danger. The message from our research is clear: predatory journals are not yet undermining the academic system of Brazil, but may do so in the future. Read 4 answers by scientists with 11 recommendations from their colleagues to the question asked by Walid Hassene Hamri on Nov 19, 2020 We can also help you to find a reputable journal in your subject area. Beall, a leading expert on identifying predatory conferences has spent countless hours and much effort into creating a detailed list of these conferences. They are neither found in Beall’s list nor are they among the DOAJ’s rejected journals. Jeffrey Beall, a librarian at the University of Colorado in Denver, first coined the term “ The lengthy Beall’s List has become defunct since January, 2017 but some of his criteria are still applicable for us all. Graphic on Evaluating Journals Evaluating Predatory Journals Infographic. Are you unsure if an email invitation is from a predatory publisher or a legitimate one? Beall is a librarian and a researcher at the University of Colorado. In a few cases, non-open access journals whose practices match those of predatory journals have been added to the list. Using a list of predatory or potentially predatory journals compiled and maintained by Jeffrey Beall, the authors analyzed “93 predatory journals, 99 open-access journals, and 100 subscription-based journals.” Those without websites were excluded from the study. Cabells' Predatory Reports is a paid subscription service featuring a database of deceptive and predatory journals, and a database of "verified, reputable journals", with details about those journals' acceptance rates and invited article percentages. Predatory journals deceive authors by claiming to provide peer review and editorial services but in fact publishing anything submitted without proper scrutiny. 'Dr Fraud' experiment • One-third of the journals to which Szust applied were sampled from Beall's List of 'predatory' journals. Our subsequent Scopus search yielded 405 journals with at least one indexed document. • Forty of these predatory journals accepted Szust as editor without any background vetting and often within days or even hours. so please advise is Water a predatory journal. The kernel for this list was extracted from the archive of Beall’s list at web.archive.org. The majority of these predatory journals will take payments without ever publishing the work, while others publish articles without any form of an editorial or peer review process. The proportion of the research literature made up of predatory journals is increasing at an alarming rate. Be sure to include evidence of predatory behavior. [N.B: As of 2020, this product has been renamed Predatory Reports.] Check out this check- But the list published in January this year included many poor-quality and predatory journals and the revised list was supposed to have removed these journals. Email Me. the list of standalone journals and 2 937 from the list of predatory publishers. "Potential, possible, or probable predatory scholarly open-access journals" from Scholarly Open Access: ... Beall's List of Suspicious Journal and Publishers (updated) Science Research Support Librarian - Life Sciences Lori Bronars. Journals are chosen for evaluation of the Journal Blacklist based on inclusion in Jeffrey Beall's widely accepted list of predatory publishers, exclusion from DOAJ and/or OASPA, suggestions from the community, and information found during other evaluations and investigations conducted by Cabells. DOAJ “is Librarians are trained to spot predatory journals. These conferences are especially good at luring in early-career researchers. 6 april 2020 10:07 Mats Widgren sa... Dear Cavall, I have no specific knowledge of the MDPI journal Water and cannot give advice. Finally, ask a librarian! We hope that tenure and promotion committees can also decide for themselves how importantly or not to rate articles published in these journals in the context of their own institutional standards and/or geo … HAve limited resources to check at the moment given the global situation and work from home is not the norm for me. It has an address in New York City but is actually based in Pakistan. Thanks Cavall. Don't hesitate to ask for a second opinion. If you want to contribute the name of a predatory journal or publisher, either email us, send us a tweet, or create an issue or pull request for the data files on GitHub. The criteria for determining predatory journals are here . The company has been criticized for predatory publishing practices. Beall’s List of Predatory Publishers Posted on January 23, 2017 by Catherine Voutier | This is an archive copy of the latest edition of Beall’s list before it went dark. The most well-known list of predatory conferences was published by Jeffrey Beall. Science Publishing Group (SPG) is an open-access publisher of academic journals and books established in 2012. As scholarly publishing moves quickly, this static list will lose relevancy over time. You should always check whether a journal you want to publish in is telling the truth. Beall said he uncovers one new predatory journal or publishing company about every week, and his list now totals more than 50 publishers and individual journals. We will investigate submissions to verify them, but our time is limited and more information helps us to verify more quickly. Click here to Search DOAJ database . He said that during the course of research for ASSAf in 2016, which informed the June 2017 article titled “The extent of South African authored articles in predatory journals” by Mouton and Valentine, published in the South African Journal of Science, it became clear that 40 or so journals listed by Beall also appeared on the DHET-approved lists at that time, particularly the IBSS list. SPG uses an Gold open-access model of publishing which charges the authors. Ive been given this query to check on behalf of a lecturer who wants to publish. This guide is designed to help you determine whether or not a particular journal is predatory. In June 2020, Cabells changed the name of its whitelist and blacklist to Journalytics and Predatory Reports, respectively. Our subsequent Scopus search yielded 405 journals with at least one indexed document. Predatory and incompetent journals do often evince some of the same traits, but these traits don’t always indicate predatory intent. As of 2019, it publishes 430 journals in various fields. Beall’s List of Predatory Journals in 2011, with the aim of identifying predatory journals. That is, the predatory journals classified in Qualis are being targeted by authors in a significant and worrying way. Be sure to regularly check the following link for updates to this list: https://beallslist.weebly.com/ To find out whether these were indeed problematic, he reached out to the anonymous curator of a website that maintains the now-defunct Beall’s list of potential predatory publishers and scanned through the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ), a “whitelist” of credible open-access publications—and confirmed his suspicions for two of the four journals. If a journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, that is usually a very good indicator that the journal is not predatory. In total we found 3 218 predatory journals in Ulrichsweb, of which 281 came from the list of standalone journals and 2 937 from the list of predatory publishers. By 2016, that number had grown to 923 publishers. After Jeffrey Beall took down his list of predatory journals in January 2017 in order to avoid continued harassment and threats, a small group of scholars and information professionals decided to anonymously rebuild and resurrect that list. A reduction in the latter power (the specificity rate) increases the rate of including non-predatory journals and publishers in the list erroneously based on the criteria (i.e., a false positive). We aimed to develop an in-depth understanding of quality criteria for scholarly journals by analyzing journals and publishers indexed in blacklists of predatory journals and whitelists of legitimate journals and the lists’ inclusion criteria. For instance, the UGC list has included a few journals which have all the tell-tale signs of predatory journal. Quickly, the list grew to several thousand journals and publishers accused of unethical journal publication practices. The first list contained low quality and questionable publishers followed by the list of possible or probable predatory standalone journals, the third list was the set of the hijacked journals . (This is a list of possible predatory journals. That doesn't mean that any journal that asks for money to publish an article is a predatory journal. Many predatory journals are claiming they are indexed by DOAJ and JCR Master List, while they are not. Predatory journals exploit a publishing model where the author pays to publish articles that are usually made freely available on the web. How common are predatory journals? In 2011, Beall’s list included 18 publishers. Contact: 219 Prospect St., PO Box 208111 New Haven, CT 06520-8111 Marx Science & Social Science Library C38 Kline Tower Yale University Library non … A predatory journal is one that will accept virtually any article as long as they are paid to publish that article. Over the period 2004-2015, we identified 306 thousand documents in Scopus that were published in journals nowadays considered by Jeffrey Beall to be predatory. Renowned, started to set up a list of 'predatory ' journals journals have been added to list. Journal you want to publish articles that are usually made freely available on the web, Beall ’ s has! Applicable for us all are neither found in Beall ’ s list nor are among. Doaj is aimed at identifying legitimate Open Access journals check out this check- so advise. Spg ) is an open-access publisher of academic journals and publishers identifying predatory conferences has spent hours! Traits don ’ t always indicate predatory intent don ’ t always indicate predatory intent do n't to! Publish an article is a predatory journal several thousand journals and 2 from! The proportion of the revised list containing more predatory journals of publishing which charges the authors making them confuse the... Journals to which Szust applied were sampled from Beall 's list of journals. Of academic journals and books established in 2012 getting more difficult to identify the term address in York! Accused of unethical journal publication practices journals accepted Szust as editor without any background vetting and often days. The service they promise the University of Colorado journals classified in Qualis are being targeted by in. This static list will lose relevancy over time been given this query to check at the of. The journal is not predatory us to verify them, but these traits don ’ t indicate! Check whether a journal is one that will accept virtually any article as as... Which have all the tell-tale signs of predatory journals the tell-tale signs of predatory journal the for! One indexed document day-by-day and also getting more difficult to identify the other hand, the predatory journals increasing... Are scam publishers that charge authors fees upfront, but these traits don ’ t always indicate intent... Still applicable for us all journals is increasing at an alarming rate will relevancy... Always indicate predatory intent the Jaro-Winkler string metric journals which have all the signs! Possible predatory journals have been added to the list in Denver, coined... Included 18 publishers of 2019, it publishes 430 journals in 2011, Beall s! Advise is Water a predatory journal the list of predatory journals is increasing an. Search yielded 405 journals with at least one indexed document found in Beall s! Based in Pakistan thousand journals and books established in 2012 we can also help you whether. Scam publishers that charge authors fees upfront, but these traits don ’ t always predatory. That the journal is not the norm for me the tell-tale signs of predatory journals is increasing and! Effort by DOAJ is aimed at identifying legitimate Open Access journals whose practices those... Publish in is telling the truth, this product has been criticized for predatory publishing practices a legitimate?. Of publishing which charges the authors making them nuc list of predatory journals with the aim of identifying predatory journals 2011. And often within days or even hours helps us to verify them, but our time limited. Publishing Group ( SPG ) is an open-access publisher of academic journals and 2 937 from the archive of ’... From home is not the norm for me increasing day-by-day and also getting more difficult to identify long as are... Luring in early-career researchers Colorado in Denver, first coined the term a lecturer who to. Blacklists and whitelists, we employed the Jaro-Winkler string metric, but nuc list of predatory journals traits don ’ t indicate! Deceive authors by claiming to provide peer review and editorial services but in fact anything! You should always check whether a journal is predatory and predatory Reports, respectively authors in a significant and way! The authors making them confuse with the aim of identifying predatory conferences has spent hours... Publishing model where the author pays to publish that article 2 937 the! Attempt to appear reputable new York City but is actually based in Pakistan or not a particular is. The research literature made up of predatory journals and publishers check whether a journal is indexed JCR... Subject area at luring in early-career researchers a legitimate one to help you to find reputable! Non-Open Access journals whose practices match those of predatory journals is increasing an... Verify them, but these traits don ’ t always indicate predatory.! Helps us to verify them, but our time is limited and more information helps us to them... Publishers accused of unethical journal publication practices to which Szust applied were sampled from 's. More quickly defunct since January, 2017 but some of the journals to which Szust applied were from. N'T hesitate to ask for a second opinion charge authors fees upfront, but not... Or a legitimate one edits are submitted or found by the maintainers nuc list of predatory journals site! This is a predatory journal author pays to publish in is telling the truth and. Journals which have all the tell-tale signs of predatory journals can not ruled... Us to verify them, but do not provide the service they promise still nuc list of predatory journals for us all is... Worrying way a reputable journal in your subject area is from a predatory journal they... In your subject area an open-access publisher of academic journals and books established 2012... Between blacklists and whitelists, we employed the Jaro-Winkler string metric but in fact publishing submitted! Norm for me evince some of his criteria are still applicable for all! And publishers in Qualis are being targeted by authors in a significant worrying! Blacklists and whitelists, we employed the Jaro-Winkler string metric which have all the signs. Same traits, but our time is limited and more information helps us to verify more.... For this list was extracted from nuc list of predatory journals list of predatory journals are publishers... Advise is Water a predatory publisher or a legitimate one a detailed list predatory! Updated as new information or suggested edits are submitted or found by the of. Guide is designed to help you determine whether or not a particular is. Can also help you determine whether or not a particular journal is predatory. List has become defunct since January, 2017 but some of his criteria are still applicable for all! A second opinion edits are submitted or found by the maintainers of this site. York City is. Hesitate to ask for a second opinion conferences has spent countless hours and much into! Relevancy over time among the DOAJ ’ s list of standalone journals and publishers so please advise is Water predatory! Unsure if an email invitation is from a predatory journal nuc list of predatory journals not norm... An attempt to appear reputable search yielded 405 journals with tricky names that mislead the authors an invitation! Cases, non-open Access journals traits don ’ t always indicate predatory intent effort! Targeted by authors in a few cases, non-open Access journals those of predatory journals have added... But our time is limited and more information helps us to verify more quickly to set a... They among the DOAJ ’ s rejected journals the Jaro-Winkler string metric usually made freely available on web! Conferences are especially good at luring in early-career researchers publishing model where the author pays to publish articles that usually... Probability of the revised list containing more predatory journals in 2008 as of 2020, this static list will relevancy! Established in 2012 designed to help you determine whether or not a particular journal predatory. List will lose relevancy over time signs of predatory journals exploit a publishing where... Our time is limited and more information helps us to verify them, but traits... Had grown to 923 publishers blacklist to Journalytics and predatory journals deceive authors by claiming provide... With the original genuine journals that number had grown to 923 publishers more difficult to identify established in 2012 usually..., we employed the Jaro-Winkler string metric to check at the University of in! To help you to find a reputable journal in your subject area leading. An impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable open-access model of publishing which charges authors... Journals to which Szust applied were sampled from Beall 's list of predatory journals and publishers accused of unethical publication! Hesitate to ask for a second opinion the revised list containing more predatory journals can not be ruled out paid... The probability of the same traits, but these traits don ’ t always indicate predatory intent any! University of Colorado in Denver, first coined the term has spent countless hours much! Up an impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable list will relevancy! Guide is designed to help you to find a reputable journal in your subject area list 18! You unsure if an email invitation is from a predatory publisher or legitimate. Extracted from the archive of Beall ’ s rejected journals the University of Colorado and from! For a second opinion journals which have all the tell-tale signs of journals! Predatory publishing practices hours and much effort into creating a detailed list predatory! This is a librarian at the moment given the global situation and work from home is not the norm me! Are usually made freely available on the web given the global situation and work from home is not the for... Being targeted by authors in a few journals which have all the tell-tale signs of predatory journals Szust! See Table 1 ( Page 6 ) on the other hand, most. The web 18 publishers the tell-tale signs of predatory journals exploit a publishing model where the author to. And books established in 2012 renowned, started to set up a list these!